GamePro gave the SNES version a mixed review. They criticized the poor controls and repetitiveness, commenting that "Almost all of Pagemaster is redundant platform jumping against the same enemies who appear over and over again." However, they praised the graphics for their colorful and effective recreations of the settings for famous novels and concluded the game "isn't bad, it just isn't as fun as it could've been."[11] The four reviewers of Electronic Gaming Monthly also considered it a just above average game. They praised the movie-like graphics and audio, but criticized the controls, saying the character tends to slide around, and felt the game to be generally uninteresting.[8] They held the Genesis version in lower regard, commenting that "This game would be enjoyable, but the control just isn't there."[7] GamePro similarly commented that the Genesis version is good in most respects, but that the poor controls make it an overall mediocre game.[10]